Growing up Iranian, American, and Female
State University of New York
A 1990 study of 101 Iranian-descent high school students and their
families resident in Santa Clara County , California showed that
parents had high expectations of their offspring, and in most cases,
the young people were meeting those expectations. While parents
generally said that their expectations were much the same whether
the adolescent was male or female, interviews with the parents
and separate interviews with 32 of the adolescents revealed several
ways in which expectations appeared to be different for the young
women. Some differences in the behavior of male and female adolescents
were also found when the interview data and the school records
of the 61 males and 40 females in the study were compared.
These
parents expected their adolescents, whether male or female, to
study diligently, achieve high grades, and prepare themselves for
higher education and professional careers. The grades and standardized
test scores of these students showed that the young women were
performing slightly better, on average, than their male counterparts.
Furthermore, all the adolescents in this sample who were doing
very poorly in school were male. These gender differences in performance
are congruent with those generally reported for U.S. populations,
both immigrant and non-immigrant.
The vast majority of the parents
interviewed did not expect to return to Iran , and they recognized
that their children needed to be able to adapt to U.S. society
and culture in order to achieve their high academic and professional
goals. Nevertheless, most the parents hoped their children would
avoid adopting at least some American traits and would retain some
Iranian traits. While the differences were small, a slightly higher
proportion of the parents of females expressed concern that their
adolescent might adopt too many American traits, and a slightly
higher proportion of the female adolescents interviewed (as compared
to the male) saw themselves as primarily Iranian (rather than Iranian-American
or primarily American).
The expectations of parents of females
differed the most from those of parents of males with respect to
peer relations and especially relations with the opposite sex.
Although many parents said that the standards and expectations
in this area too should be the same for male and female adolescents,
interview data suggested that parents monitored and restricted
the social activities of the young women more than they did those
of the young men. Other studies of Iranian immigrants have also
reported a double standard with respect to supervision of adolescents,
especially with respect to dating and contact with members of the
opposite sex.
Parents' greater concern about their daughters' social
activities may be related to the somewhat greater concern expressed
by some parents of daughters that their child not adopt too many
American cultural traits, and retain more of the good traits of
Iranian cultures (among which they tended to count chastity and
adherence to traditional family values). This could also be related
to the young women's somewhat higher academic performance; fewer
social activities may mean more time to study, and parents' greater
restrictiveness may generate more positive attitudes about school.
Maintenance of somewhat stronger ties with the ethnic culture has
also been shown in some studies to be related to higher academic
achievement. All the findings reported here, however, must be considered
suggestive rather than definitive, since the sample was small,
the gender differences subtle, and possible confounding variables
not controlled.
Acknowledgements: This research
was supported by the National Science Foundation, Grant # BNS -8920612,
and carried out with the assistance of Ms. Nahid Azad, Marriage
and Family Counselor. Thanks are due to the many Iranian parents,
adolescents, and community members who participated in the study,
and to the educational personnel who generously cooperated with
the research.